Mutual Funds or ULIPs: Which one is a better deal?
Tuesday, January 13, 2009 1:00 amWith innumerable investment and saving options in the market, it’s become quite easy to have your pick! However, one must be cautious. Everyone likes to see their hard earned money grow and quickly. But there are no quick gains. An investment has to be long term in order to be truly beneficial. As you make up your mind to invest, make sure you are ready to keep patience. Besides, risk factor is always there to accompany your investment. So, you should be absolutely clear in your mind, what you want. Whether it’s Life Insurance Policy, National Savings Certificate or Mutual Funds, all the investment plans have their pros and cons that you need to weigh before you proceed. Unit Linked Insurance Plans are also gaining popularity these days for their investor-friendly profile.
Mutual Funds as an investment plan have the potential to reward you richly in the long run. However, fluctuating market graphs would give you sleepless nights. So, it’s not really an inviting prospect in the present scenario. Of course, you can’t write it off completely. But one has to take it easy and not rush into any investment plan without educating oneself about it thoroughly. Unit Linked Insurance Plans have come like a ray of sunshine on a gloomy day! Not that it ensures you 100% returns but it certainly does sound promising.
As far as Mutual Funds are concerned, they will remain a lucrative option as long as you invest wisely. Invest in diversified funds. All the sectors in the market can’t be losers at the same time. If one is not doing well, you can rely on the other. As mentioned earlier, long term investment is the key to rewarding returns. Market is likely to go through many changes during a year or so. Systematic Investment Plan should be the ideal way to invest in mutual funds, which keeps you aside from market’s volatility. Even if market is not in the positive zone, you can still stay invested. Brushing everything aside, Mutual Funds are a good investment option for the tax-saving benefits.
Unit Linked Insurance Plans are an investment plan along with an insurance coverage, so that sets it apart, indeed. It gives you freedom to invest in equity or debt fund and also have up to four switches in a year. You can go for a long-term or short-term investment depending on the market conditions. Even if markets are low, one can keep the plan alive to enjoy the life coverage. Like other investment plans, this one also comes with tax-saving benefits. The returns from ULIPs are 100% tax free, which allows you to use it as an endowment policy also. A typical insurance scheme does not have an option to increase your sum assured at a later date, however with ULIPs, you can increase your risk cover at any stage in your policy period. ULIPs also allow you to withdraw funds as and when required as long as you are making minimum payments.
Both Mutual Funds and ULIPs have high liquidity with freedom to use your money the way you want. Nonetheless, one must plan the investment with utmost care and vigilance. It’s better not to have any returns then loosing everything. So, the smarter option is to go for long-term and diversified investments.
ULIPs certainly have an edge over Mutual Funds for their life insurance aspect. Mutual Funds, however are long established and renowned with more coveted returns as long as market is hunky-dory. ULIPs are comparatively safer and welcoming as far as returns are concerned.
It’s up to you, what you are looking for as an investor. Are you looking for high returns and willing to wait for as long as 2-3 years or you simply want a stable investment policy that will keep your life insured too?
In the current context, ULIPs would be a better deal for small investors.

Ranjeet Jha says:
March 31st, 2009 at 12:02 pm
Sir,
What is the fundamental difference between a ULIP and Market Linked Pension plan of HDFC. I am looking at buying a policy @10,000 pm for 25 years. A reply is highly appreciated.
Regards,
ajay shah says:
April 16th, 2009 at 5:15 pm
Sir,
Whether maturity amt under ULIP & ULPP are taxable or tax free? Can i withdraw some amt every month (like monthly pension) under ULIP scheme? Where to invest maturity corpus under ULIP? Does it remain invested with the same insurer or investor wil have option to invest in annuity of any other insurer?
Thnx
Sarita says:
May 26th, 2009 at 4:33 pm
Hi Ranjeet,
The fundamental difference between ULIP & Market Linked Pension Plan by HDFC (i.e. ULPP) is that ULIP refers to Unit-lInked LIFE INSURANCE plan where as ULPP is Unit Linked PENSION plan. There is a difference in how the maturity amounts are disbursed. In ULIPs upon maturity u r paid out the Total Fund Value in lumpsum (or some plans have Settlement option wherein u can take that amount equally spread over 5 yrs from the Date of maturity) but incase of ULPP, upon maturity or the vesting age (the date from which u wish to receive ur pension payout) u have an option to take only 1/3rd of the Total maturity amount (Fund Value) in lumpsum, however of the remaining 2/3rd u’ll have to buy an annuity plan either from the same Co. or some other Life Insurance company in the market and u can receive your pension payouts depending on the mode u have chosen from that provider (either monthly, quarterly, half-yearly or yearly)
iqwal khan...... says:
August 31st, 2009 at 5:25 pm
Hiiii
Hayy guys if u r thing for less than 15 year than u must go with mutual fund but if u r thinking for more than 15 yr than u must go with a good ulip plan life birla sun life insurance’s classsic life premier……….
Neil says:
December 12th, 2009 at 12:29 am
Hi,
I amlooking for ivesting options for a long term, what do u suggest a mutual fund or a ULIP
Srikanth Matrubai says:
January 2nd, 2010 at 10:18 pm
ULIPs are a clear rip-off. They are the most mis-sold product in India. Mutual Funds are clear winners.
RAMESH says:
January 28th, 2010 at 12:37 pm
IDBI FORTIS IS HAVING THE BEST EVER ULIP PLAN.NO GIMMICKS.CLEAR CUT RETURNS.
Shan Bose says:
February 15th, 2010 at 4:28 pm
Its a common confusion on which is the best investment option. Mutual funds are cheaper, But only in the short run. Over a long period (may be 15 - 20 yrs)ULIP will give you a better return over Mutual funds as the fund management charges are lower than mutual funds. Its a small factor but the FMC are taken on a daily basis by NAV adjestment and over a long period it will eat in to your fund value. Also there are other charges pretaining to MF such as marketing expenses, Custodian charges, Trustee fee, audit fee which are not visible to the investors. Also tax bebefits are not available in mutual funds except for ELSS. ULIPS also provide valuable insurance cover at a cost lesser than Term insurance plans. So a combination Term and Mutual funds is costiler than stand alone ULIP ove the long run.
Norbert Hardisty says:
December 4th, 2011 at 7:20 pm
In the business world, most people are paid by 50 percent coins: cash and experience. Take the experience first; the cash can come later.